Back to overview
October 26, 2021

Neighbour disputes: is your insurance up to date?

The courts have recently been granted a large number of new measures aimed at resolving disputes between neighbours and neighbourhood conflicts. Conflicts of this nature also affect policyholders who want to take out insurance cover for this purpose. Robert Bernard, Senior Advisor at Vanbreda Risk & Benefits, explains.

Burenhinder

A new law concerning neighbourhood disputes took effect on 1 September of this year. What is new is that judges now have considerably more scope to impose measures. With the previous regulation (art. 544) the outcome of a court case almost always required the guilty party to pay a certain amount to the injured party as financial compensation for the damage incurred. This measure still applies. For instance, if the walls of a house develop cracks because of major building work being carried out on an adjoining site, a judge may decide that these cracks must be repaired at the builder’s expense.

Compensatory measures

However, judges have now been given a number of additional options, i.e. they can also impose compensatory measures. For example, the court may order a developer to make modifications to a damaged property to ensure that the injured party is no longer inconvenienced by the work. Moreover, the judge may also decree that the nuisance activities be suspended in order to reduce them to an acceptable level. For example, if a construction company wakes up the residents in the houses adjoining the construction site using jackhammers and drilling machines at 6 o’clock every morning, the judge may decree that the work must not commence before a specific, more acceptable time.

Compensation? Or not?

These new measures consequently do not immediately result in compensation for the damage incurred, although they usually do have a financial impact. Construction work that can only commence hours later than planned each day will probably result in additional expenditure for the construction company, but legally this will not be considered damage compensation. This also has repercussions for insurers and insurance policy holders. All in all, insurance policies do not cover liability for nuisance caused by neighbours, they only provide compensation for damage arisen as a result of this nuisance. This means that an insurer does not actually have to intervene in the payment of costs if they do not constitute compensation for damage.

Preventive measures

It goes even further, because another new measure stipulates that a judge can now also impose preventive measures to avoid neighbourhood nuisance. Suppose, for example, that a construction company wants to develop a site, but the adjoining plot contains a house that is known to have old and weak foundations. In such cases it may be decreed that the foundations must be strengthened at the expense of the construction company if the house is at risk of subsidence. Again, this is not considered compensation, although it will have a significant impact on the final cost of the construction project.

Coordinating clauses

This new legislation (articles 3.101 and 3.102 of the Civil Code) now provides a more extensive definition of the concept of abnormal neighbourhood nuisance. This in turn could lead to more measures being taken to compensate or prevent nuisance. However, the financial consequences of these measures will not always be guaranteed. The need to coordinate clauses in contracts and guarantees in insurance policies has, therefore, become even greater than before. Being a specialist broker in the construction sector, Vanbreda Risk & Benefits can provide the necessary advice in this respect. We have already adapted any relevant clauses in our own policies to comply with this amended legislation. Our claims department for the construction sector is obviously closely monitoring the development of these new laws.

BERO 1 150x150
Robert Bernard
Senior Claims Advisor Construction

Related posts

Aflevering 15 Vanbreda S2 Foto website

Videopodcast — Legislative changes

Videopodcast
18.02.2025

In the latest episode of our video podcast Succes Verzekerd, find out how you can successfully include new risks in your company’s risk management approach. A panel of four in-house experts explains the recent legislative changes affecting your insurance portfolio, focusing on four topical areas: auxiliary party liability, mobility, solar panels and cyber.

Read more
Read more about Videopodcast - Legislative changes
U7353792727 Photorealistic image three people in a business mee 82c0813c cc51 4d46 a79b 1a665b1f44a3

What does Book 6 mean for the position and protection of auxiliary parties?

Liability
14.02.2025

What do auxiliary party liability, mobility, solar panels and cyber have in common? They are four factors that affect your company’s risk profile in 2025. In the latest episode of our video podcast Succes Verzekerd, a panel of in-house experts discusses how you can successfully include new risks in your company’s risk management approach. We start the series with Anouk Dehing: what type of liability are auxiliary parties at risk of incurring following the introduction of Book 6?

Read more
Read more about What does Book 6 mean for the position and protection of auxiliary parties?
Pexels cottonbro 5990042

The new Book 6 of the Civil Code: impact on existing liability policies also limited for the social profit and public sectors (Part 2)

Liability
13.12.2024

The introduction of the new Book 6 of the Civil Code, which will come into effect on 1 January 2025, raises numerous questions about directors’ liability and civil liability insurance policies.

In this second article, we explain what a directors’ liability policy covers – and whether any modification is required in light of the new Book 6 of the Civil Code.

Read more
Read more about The new Book 6 of the Civil Code: impact on existing liability policies also limited for the social profit and public sectors (Part 2)
I Stock 939501750

The new Book 6 of the Civil Code: impact on existing liability policies also limited for the social profit and public sectors (Part 1)

Liability
12.12.2024

The introduction of the new Book 6 of the Civil Code, which will come into effect on 1 January 2025, raises numerous questions about directors’ liability and civil liability insurance policies.

In this first article, we explain the impact on the civil liability policy – and whether any modification is required in light of the new Book 6 of the Civil Code.

Read more
Read more about The new Book 6 of the Civil Code: impact on existing liability policies also limited for the social profit and public sectors (Part 1)
CTA Image

Further information?

Would you like further information or advice specifically tailored to your company? If so, please do not hesitate to contact our colleague via the e-mail address below.